Saturday, August 22, 2020

ODALIS SANTANA EXPLAINS WHY RETURNING TO SCHOOL IS SO HARD

 This is from ABC news:

After her mother's death in April from COVID-19, Odalis Santana changed her voicemail message.

"Thank you all for the outpouring of love that you have given my family during this difficult time. I know that my mother would appreciate it," Santana's voice says on the tape. It's now August, but her fresh grief from the spring, captured on the recording, cuts through. "Thank you all for your texts, your messages, your emails. We really appreciate it. Our family really appreciates it."

Santana, 46, works as a universal literacy coach at an elementary school in the Bronx, where she supports teachers with young students who are struggling with reading.

She recalled her last days in the classroom in mid-March. Santana had asked her mother, Ana, to stay with her because of the pandemic. It wasn't an unusual request. Her mother often helped Santana, a single mother, with childcare, and Santana didn't want to leave her mother, who lived in public housing for seniors, alone. Besides, in addition to being mother and daughter, the pair were close friends -- "twins," Santana said.

On April 1, they got tested together for COVID-19. The tests came back positive. Santana's two children and her brother tested positive, as well. Santana was asymptomatic, but within days, Ana, who was struggling to breathe, was hospitalized. In the early hours of the morning of April 10, Santana received a phone call. Her mother's heart had stopped.

"The last time I saw her was when I sent her to the hospital by herself," said Santana, who used to talk to her mother on the phone multiple times each day. "I never got to say goodbye."

While Santana will never know whether she picked up the virus at school, she thinks back on the days when New York City restaurants and bars were shuttered, but teachers were still going into the classroom, regretfully.

"I’m just angry that we were told to go back to work without knowing what was happening," she said.

She doesn't blame the principal at her school, who she says, was "clueless, just like we were," about the pandemic back in March. But she's frustrated that Mayor Bill de Blasio and New York City Schools Chancellor Richard Carranza are pushing to reopen schools in person in September.

As the fall approaches, the issue of whether to reopen New York City schools, which were closed on March 16, to in-person learning has been hotly contested.

Futher down:

New York's case positivity rate (the rate of positive cases to total tests) has been consistently below 1% in recent weeks, an indication that the virus is currently under control.

But those statistics belie the horror witnessed by educators and students last spring, particularly in black and Latino neighborhoods, when more than 20,000 residents died of the virus. New York City schools weren't spared the devastation. As of June, 79 department of education employees, 31 of them teachers, had died of COVID-19, according to the department.

Sorry for your loss, Odalis. My wife lost her grandmother from COVID-19 in April. This is a tragic time in our history.

If you can't understand why so many UFTers are reluctant to go back to school buildings, you have to try to remember what UFTers have been through already. Nobody trusts the DOE or the city to keep staff and students safe. 

38 comments:

Pete Zucker said...

Odalis is a good person and didn’t need this crap. I worked with her for 6 weeks my first year as an ATR. She has the backs of everyone. She’s been through a lot of pain. I hope getting her story out there helps.

Anonymous said...

As a parent and educator I am now completely at a loss for words. I am watching an outdoor building in a schoolyard (quarantine ?) and seeing yesterday the city cut FDNY and EMIts. Our heroes supposedly. Teachers are also heroes and sheroes!!! Must they be doomed by their fate?

Anonymous said...

https://news.yahoo.com/covid-classroom-shhh-schools-keeping-141211721.html

Schools Hiding COVID-19 Cases

Anonymous said...

https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/school-report-card-this-week-a-sickout-protest-shuts-down-schools-in-arizona-205458328.html

Other School Districts in the Country

Anonymous said...

In addition to the almost guaranteed covid spread as teachers and students congregate in school buildings...What is going on with safety in NYC? Every day there are many shootings and robberies, now there are train windows being smashed. When is this going to be stopped? Is this the wild, wild west? Should teachers and students risk getting shot on the way to work? How about getting hit with a pipe on a train? This is now a widespread problem in NYC. I ask you to assist in immediately arresting criminals and keeping them in jail. This has gotten pathetic. The mayor clearly has no ability to deal with this issue.

Anonymous said...

This is a very sad story. The thought that they can even think of opening the schools for in-person instruction is unconscionable. Some buildings even with the split schedules will have hundreds, and in some schools over a thousand or more students and staff in an indoor setting for many hours each day.

It's ridiculous to think that the virus will not spread in those conditions (safety protocols in place or not) and subsequently cause the death of people in this city. Either students and staff, their family members or people they encounter on the buses and trains on the way to and from school.

People will die. To think otherwise is to not have observed the nature of this virus over the past 6 months.

D75 said...

NYC teachers are cowards.

Anonymous said...

@6:55 - It is quite a shame. You would think NYC teachers would be leading the national movement in militancy and advocacy for safety. Embarrassing.

Anonymous said...

No D75, we are not. We are just not stupid. We just know the DOE doesn’t care if teachers and students get sick and die-or bring it home to their families so they can get sick and die. In March they didn’t tell teachers in my school when their students had Covid- thankfully the kids told the teachers. No one contacted the teacher to contact trace.

Why would teachers trust the DOE now?

Anonymous said...

I am a NYC teacher. I have emailed multiple times. Still, nothing has been done to move to remote learning for the fall term. I would say 90% of the staff are uncomfortable being in buildings with the rest of the staff and students. We are setting up for more suffering, outbreaks and death.

How many days in a row am I going to read stories like this? It is getting worse everyday. Does anybody care about the safety of the teachers and students? Are we just walking into covid, gunshots and theft?

NYC grocers alarmed by uptick in theft, quality of life crimes - New York Daily News

Anonymous said...

In the end there will be no strike. There will be no work stoppage, there will be no nothing.
Teachers will simply report to there schools and do what they are told.

Anonymous said...

New York has suffered 20,000 more deaths than any other state, says
@TianaTheFirst

So why is @NYGovCuomo writing a book about his "leadership" during the pandemic?

Tiana calls out the media for ignoring thousands of nursing home deaths due to his FAILED leadership.

Anonymous said...

Everything that De Blasio does turns to shit.

Anonymous said...

In-person schooling is a scheme to prepare to layoff teachers.
The DOE-approved Stuyvesant plan leaves 40% teachers in excess with only 5 periods a school day. As soon as Cuomo reduces funding to NYC public schools, DOE will let go teachers fast.

Anonymous said...

If an employer is aware there is an above-normal risk of COVID-19 in their workplace, they need to inform employees of the heightened risk.

We are talking about the NYC DOE which won't admit to anything.

Anonymous said...

https://patch.com/new-york/parkslope/brooklyn-principals-gravely-concerned-school-reopening

Brooklyn Principals 'Gravely Concerned' About School Reopening
34 principals from District 15 — which stretches from Carroll Gardens to Sunset Park — are among those asking for a delay on reopening.

Shelley said...

The obsession with dues and the dues check off, an emotional, angry, and surely, for many, a justified obsession, is not helpful to our current movement to forge solidarity and take action. First off, the obsession is simply wrong when it exaggerates, as our enemies exaggerate, the value of dues. Of course, unions AND their opposition grossly exaggerated the Janus battle and its consequences. It was a minor battle. The war continues and the battle over dues is not going to decide the war. What will decide it is solidarity. Can we hold together? Dues and Janus helped, at first, motivate and unify members but now it is a distraction, it is divisive now and needs to be tabled in the interest of the threats we face.

The opposition to Unity has to support the union now. Yes, it sucks to have them with all the money and resources. But that is our reality and talking of dues is not going to change that reality. After we get passed our triple threat, September re-opening and/or remote (a double edged threat as re-opening threatens our lives and remote threatens our livelihood), October budget, November elections, we can take up dues and and how we confront Unity's power structure, but right now we need everyone focused on our first threat.

And we are losing focus and momentum is flagging. Where is that letter James posted? The one that CL were to send out? Anyone seen that? What is the agenda for the CL meetings that have been called? Anyone know? What is the job action plan? Who is planning it? While Randy said she supports so-called safety strikes, what support will we get? There are many concerned about their bills? Will we established a strike fund? Will other unions be called on to donate monies to NY teachers? What's the budget for a job action? Who is organizing the publicity? So on... I don't hear or see any action and time, as the lawyers say, is of the essence.

I have delimited the reasons for our inherent, legal, political, weakness, but by far our biggest weakness is that we don't act like a union. Members are apathetic and fell neglected. The major opposition groups are agreeing to a united action here, but where be that action. We had better stop talking about dues and start mobilizing people. Or we will fail. Failure will be disastrous.

waitingforsupport said...

@D75...are you a coward?

Anonymous said...

New York Gov. Cuomo warns NYC restaurants may have to close again in the fall
PUBLISHED WED, AUG 19 2020 1:22 PM EDT
UPDATED THU, AUG 20 2020 6:35 PM EDT

But open schools???

While every region of New York is in the final phase of reopening, New York City has been barred from reopening many indoor activities.
Gov. Andrew Cuomo has recently laid the groundwork for some indoor businesses to return in the coming weeks with limited capacity, including gyms and museums.

Anonymous said...

NY Times

Covid in the Classroom? Some Schools Are Keeping It Quiet
Some states and school districts provide detailed data on school outbreaks. Others choose to keep such information under wraps.

Anonymous said...

Scott Gottlieb, MD
@ScottGottliebMD

New York City's Covid website now shows #COVID19 antibody test results by ZIP code. There's a clear correlation between higher poverty rates in a zip code and a higher Covid infection burden. https://on.nyc.gov/319ATlb

Anonymous said...

Scott Gottlieb, MD
@ScottGottliebMD

The U.S. is still averaging about 45K new cases per day of Covid, with about 40,000 people hospitalized.

Anonymous said...

We need to strike for health, safety and working conditions. When are we going to be told who is going to be teaching students on their hybrid remote days and who is teaching full remote? Classroom teacher cannot do both and DeBozio saying "somethings will work themselves out as they are done" is not an answer. I feel like they want to try to dump it on the classroom teachers last minute because they know full well they don't have anyone to do it.

Anonymous said...

Unless a vaccine is available, I would wait until after flu season.

Trump making major medical announcement tonight, he says.

Anonymous said...

Gotta be honest, I'm not even comfortable walking near my school building or walking through NYC with all the violence. When is that going to be solved? Then we have covid...No way I'm going...

Anonymous said...

They dont have nurses or custodial staff yet...Still hiring.

Several Brooklyn districts are saying they are completely mismatched in terms of having the right amount of teachers, they dont.

Cuomo said it is up to staff and parents...Most dont want to go in.

Anonymous said...

The NYC Mayor and the DOE Chancellor are promising at least one nurse per building this school year. These positions aren’t even remotely close to being filled (not to mention the nurses union are adamantly opposed to their current reopening plan). The job postings for nurses are still live and current. Nurses are required to have six weeks of training/orientation. But there are less than three weeks left for school buildings to open. The mayor and chancellor are the men formulating the most important plan for our safety and health, yet some of you still will blindly support them and turn your back on your fellow UFT members

Anonymous said...

I agree with what someone else posted about covid safety and gun safety and overall crime safety. Who thinks it is safe to walk in the streets these days?

NYC SHOOTINGS: At least 30 people shot, 7 dead in gun violence this weekend

Anonymous said...

Dear all,

Mayoral control means
@NYCMayor
has the last and final word on school reopening.

And let’s not forget that
@UFT
President Michael Mulgrew has been at the table on this since day one.

Neither of these men should be let off the hook for this disaster.

Anonymous said...

An Ohio 4th-grader who was diagnosed with coronavirus and spent parts of four months in the hospital has died.

Dorielis Reyes, 9, died at Cincinnati Children's Hospital. Her ailments were called a medical mystery by the doctors at the hospital.

Pete Zucker said...

Ding Dong is announcing what is already known and being used. Plasma from those who’ve had COVID is being used. It’s promising. 60 Minutes did piece in June. But they still need more info.

Anonymous said...

This 61 year old teacher is willing to teach remotely starting Sept. 10. But I’m not willing to die from COVID. #IwillnotdieforDOE I choose remote, just like my students families did.
@MindyRosier

@TeacherArthurG

@NYCMayor

waitingforsupport said...

So in other words Cuomo Dibozoess and Mulgrusome are saying you're on your own. They can possibly spin it as: Hey, le laid out the facts and these "essential teachers chose" to go in. "Hey folks, hug a teacher because they are true heroes." Egad.

jj said...

Day 151 of the Cuomo/DeBlasio shutdown...But open schools.

Anonymous said...

Why doesnt Cuomo fire DeBlasio??

Anonymous said...

How does one apply to become a school nurse?
i know someone who may be interested and is Overly qualified for the job

Reno said...

Honestly, coming from someone on the younger side, this field has left me quite dis-enchanted. It seems that education is on a trend towards being privatized. This is very common in India, which is where my parents immigrated from. Public schools kept getting the short end of the stick, to the point where they basically had the reputation of being holes in a wall - parents, even the most modest of them all, started sending their kids to private English schools instead (even if they barely can afford it). It's like that here with parents in districts with poor schools sending their kids to charter schools or private schools.

It's a shame. This city has become a joke, from the city agencies, to the crime uptick, to students barely graduating and grade inflation.

We need a renaissance to bring back the old days of education - one where tough love wasn't seen as being harsh. One where we don't need to be walking on eggshells and being afraid of not being PC. One where administrators are teachers with years of experience. One where teachers are familiar with their school community and not transplants from Ohio, who are the exact reason why NYC became so overrated and nauseatingly fake.

I understand the fears of those who are against the strike. But if we don't fight back now, even if the outcome is one that has already been pre-determined by Mulgrew or DeBlasio or Cuomo, we'll never be taken seriously.

I truly hope from the bottom of my heart that the respect for education and educators increases. People in this country take education for granted and don't know how good they have it compared to other countries. However, it is this taking for granted that has put us in the situation we are in today. We aren't preserving it.

Stay safe everyone. Remember, we have to support each other. If teachers don't have each others backs, might as well call education educorporate where everyone are backstabbers.

waitingforsupport said...

Right on Reno. Stay safe.