The Official Blog of the Independent Community of Educators, a caucus of the United Federation of Teachers
Saturday, January 27, 2007
ICE Platform - Countering the Attacks on Teachers and Schools
We demand:
1. A return to more manageable workloads for teachers and other school staff.
Two rounds of time-for-money swaps have severely compromised the conditions for learning in the city schools. We must fight the false notion that “productivity” can be increased simply by extending the time of instruction. The teacher's school day must include time for planning, student conferences and consultation among faculty.
2. Ending attacks and discrimination against senior teachers.
Experienced teachers are crucial for any school. Only the most short-sighted and irresponsible management would be so hostile to them. Teachers who have successfully taught for years in a school should be secure in their jobs.
3. Enhancing the rights of new teachers.
Klein and Bloomberg have worked to greatly increase the number of new teachers which has changed the makeup of the teaching force. We call for a shorter probationary period to increase the proportion of teachers with tenure. New teachers must be protected against abuse by administrators and supported with meaningful professional development, mentoring and support.
4. Small classes with enforceable limits.
Equity with other districts in the state should only be the immediate target. Ultimately class-size reduction should meet children's needs which are greater in high-poverty, urban areas than in the suburbs. The lack of funding for the upgrading and building of new schools is the main cause of oversized classes which is a violation of our students' civil rights and should be treated as such.
5. Ending high-stakes testing and all other inappropriate testing of students.
Testing should be primarily used for diagnostic purposes and support educational goals, not distort them. Examples of inappropriate testing are
· forcing all English Language Learners (ELL) to take the English Language Arts exams
· inflicting standardized reading tests on children before they reach the third grade
· making all high school students take the PSAT
Evaluation of students and decisions about their progress should be made locally by those most familiar with them. Students should be able to demonstrate their learning in a variety of ways.
6. A broadening of school curricula to address long-term educational goals.
Civic participation in a democratic society must be reincorporated into the education of New York City schools. We demand the restoration of subjects that have been shortchanged because of the craze for short-term results on math and reading tests, including music, art, vocational training, health, foreign language, sports and technology. This must also include an end to mandated methods of teaching practices and strong guarantees of academic freedom for teachers and students.
7. An end to the over-reliance on standardized testing for qualifying teachers.
One of the results of relying exclusively on standardized tests and the labyrinth of requirements for new teachers has been a relative decrease in the number of black, Latino and non-native English speakers among the teaching staff. Alternative paths to qualify as teachers should be reinstated. School workers, including paras and school aides should have an opportunity to turn their school experience into better school jobs.
8. School improvement planning that provides a significant role for teachers.
Teachers must have a meaningful voice in the running of their school. Our union must take a clear stand against privatization of school services and management. We must resist the national crusade to punish and condemn schools on the basis of test scores. Let's push instead for transparency in school governance, oversight by elected boards and councils and broader community input into how schools function.
Thank you for ariculating, clearly and precisely, the platform of change I already knew ICE stands for. You and TJC have my enthusiastic support in the upcoming election.
ReplyDeleteICE-TJC in 2007!
Joe Mudgett
Chairman, ACT! Alliance of Concerned Teachers
I wish you had called this piece
ReplyDelete"Our Platform" or anything else instead of "Demands". It sounds too radical and we know they won't all be met.
Do you wish to come off as radical or as a viable alternative?
You got my vote. I will tell others as well.
ReplyDeleteIt's campaign season again for the United Federation of Teachers. UFT President Randi Weingarten is spending hundreds of thousands, if not millions of our dues dollars, on a professionally produced TV commercial that appears on Law and Order, the Today show, and who knows what else. It makes passing mention of class size, which Ms. Weingarten failed to bring up in contract negotiations, urges the public to listen to teachers, then posts Ms. Weingarten's name prominently for all the world to see.
ReplyDeleteThis is not the sort of message that keeps us from being vilified in the press, nor is it designed to do so (Dues money is not wasted on such things). Like previous UFT commercials (that also appeared during UFT campaigns) with messages like "It's not fair" (really), these commercials are aimed at The Help. That's you and me.
When The Help gets uppity, it sometimes runs candidates against Ms. Weingarten. I'm not talking about New Action (who now know their place) but ICE-TJC, which actually opposes her and is not beholden with patronage jobs. Sometimes The Help just doesn't do what it's told (and it's hard to get good Help nowadays).
Here's one example, from a comment Teacher J made last night:
NYCE, please help me get my head around our mafia-style teacher's union.
Another teacher at my school who's a member of TJC, the opposition to Unity/NA in the coming elections, was putting leaflets in the teacher mailboxes of another school in our building. Later, he gets hauled into a room to be scolded by the principal of our school, the principal of the other school, and the chapter chair of the other school, who all essentially told him that they had taken the leaflets out of the mailbox and thrown them away, and that they were going to try to get a letter put in his file. He pointed out that DoE policy explicitly protects campaign activities if done outside work hours (he put the leaflets in the mailboxes during his lunch period). They replied in so many words that what he was doing was reprehensible and the principal has to authorize what teachers receive in their mailboxes.
What do you and your readers think this teacher can do to allow his democratic rights to be respected by the school and the union?
Yesterday, only 340 people read this blog. What were the chances this would happen to one of them? What are the chances, if this happened to one of them, that it's happening all over the city? And how many teachers don't even know opposition messages are being tossed into the trash?
Total monopoly is required to maintain the Unity patronage mill, and it's not going to let The Help get in its way. The 50-year-old Unity caucus, as always requiring signed loyalty oaths and total fealty (expelling members for opposing the Vietnam war, according to David Selden in The Teacher Rebellion), has certain standards to uphold.
Don't expect Randi Weingarten to get off her pedestal and debate The Help. That's unheard of. Not having access to dues money, and being strictly working class, the only thing The Help can afford is putting flyers into mailboxes. But Unity doesn't like that, and the administration doesn't like when The Help gets uppity. Without Ms. Weingarten and Unity, who will keep The Help in line?
What would happen if The Help found out what was really in that 05 contract? What would happen if The Help began to understand what cost of living was? What would happen if The Help found out New Action was a front for Unity?
I speak with my fellow Help every day. I am amazed at the number of intelligent and articulate teachers who have no idea about these things. Certainly neither Ms. Weingarten nor her patronage employees understand that the union is us, and that union employees (theoretically) work for us.
Against all odds, we need to get the word out.
When we do, we the people will run the union, and UFT HQ will contain The Help.
Posted by NYC Educator at 7:29 AM
NYC Educator is on to something here.
ReplyDeleteThe word "reform" has been hijacked. The new meaning includes: more work for less pay; getting rid of higher paid and independent-minded teachers; giving new teachers the sink-or-swim treatment; abolishing union protections; instituting educational mandates, no matter how inappropriate or unrealistic; putting high-stakes testing on a pedestal; relieving the government of health care and pension burdens;.....
ReplyDeleteThat the UFT leaders continue to talk about reform in the same manner as Bloomberg/Klein just shows their lack of seriousness in defending teachers and public education.
To 8:38 a.m.
ReplyDeleteI guess we could change we demand to we will beg for so we can sound like Unity.
Voted No said...
ReplyDeleteTeachers are the meekest workers that I have ever seen. They vote for these contracts then complain that they can't find a job after their school closes. You idiots are the reason that people like me who voted no will now have to find a job in a system that went back to the Tammany Hall era. Thanks a lot.
11:13 AM, January 27, 2007
I'm sure Unity can agree that most of these are worthy goals. The question is how would ICE achieve them?
ReplyDeleteUnity has not achieved anything.
Besides NYC Educator's rant and attempt to be clever, it seems like you're grasping at straws. NYC Educator know the rules about literature during campaign season (ask James Eterno). So why write it? To pontiifcate. I just wish I knew who Kit is (besides being chapter leader of Leon Goldstein HS)and what he stands for? Why is it that I never heard (read) him before? Why doesn't he say something instead of it always being James Eterno and Jeff Kaufman?
ReplyDeleteTJC's website is so lame! Why are you guys with them and why are you supporting Kit?
ReplyDeleteJeff knows he is speaking to his choir so demand might be the correct word, but Jeff is supposed to be reaching the full rank and file, and his style of writing is important in a time like this.
ReplyDeleteBoth ICE and TJC have the means to hire someone to achieve this message, but obviously they must feel that since they won't win, why bother.
And, why do we know so little about these candidates. In this time of web-media, we should all be able to see and hear their platforms. Of course I for one hope they hire someone to produce because they may be fine teachers and know union rules, but they know squat about marketing media.
Why in the world does anyone think ICE-TJC have the means to hire someone? They are teachers. Do you think they tithe? Weingarten uses the UFT machinery which she claims is separate from Unity to promote themselves. Unity has s dues structure on its own and they have possibly 2 thousand members.
ReplyDeleteUnity has charged at times that the opposition is being funded by Bloomberg. If Mayor Mike didn't really back Weingarten (for obvious reasons) he might come up with a donation.
Sorry guys, but if I were seriously running, I would put up some of my own money to do it correctly!! I would even take out a pension loan. I am not talking hundreds of thousands here.
ReplyDeleteThe point being is that the opposition has yet to investigate the cost of having someone write their material or produce a webcast for them. And if they did, how many companies or free-lance people did they contact???
This is not the time to be CHEAP, but unfortunately many teachers are, including, I am sorry to say, men. Everytime I go to a rally or DA, I am appauled by the way the men dress!! In this day and age there are many outlets to buy nice clothes and get a stylish haircut and stylish glasses or contacts and a brow wax. (the pain is worth it) Why look like a constestant for a geek on Beauty and the Geeks?? The best part of that show is when the Beauties make them over.
But more importantly, the writing needs to be improved in order to meet the masses and not just those who visit this site. I would be willing to put stuff in mailboxes, and I know my principal will let me, if I thought the writing was something my teachers would read and not just throw in the trash!
Remember the majority of the votes come from the elementary level and those votes are mostly female. And they don't like scare tactics. They vote for what is comfortable.
If you are not going to think like a marketer, than why go through the motions. I think Randi is worried and that is why she is pulling out the big ads. But a good grassroots campaign has been known to win presidential elections. Just know the whole audience and not just those who blast Randi with stupid remarks.
And yes, Class size needs to be a major issue in the contract if you are going to make "demands".
Elementary teachers don't care who the HS rep is? The issues or "demands" as you call them have to be something that first addresses the elementary level and not union politics.
And for those "Annons" who don't understand this, you need to do more research on this subject. And yes, fashion plays a part too.
When one thinks about the salary union bosses make, it would be worth the investment.
ReplyDeleteICE should produce a targeted elementary school leaflet. What are the issues of interest? Naturally, class size. In the past there were things like the ECLAS testing. What are the issues today, aside from the 37 minutes, which gets the most conversation going.
ReplyDeleteICE just hired a fashion consultant and five media advisors. We will be sure to dress appropriately at all UFT functions. The next rally will be a black tie affair. Then, we will be sure to win over those properly attired UFT members.
ReplyDeleteAt the DA we will also be rolling out a red carpet. Joan Rivers and her daughter will be commenting on everyone's dress. Now, we are talking about the real issues that concern the people in the schools. We are serious.
Great news! Nothing turns a female voter off more than a geek.
ReplyDeleteThere is another new policy to help ICE. We have hired new personal trainers to go along with our fashion consultants. Randi better look out now when she sees those sharped dressed buffed up ICE people.
ReplyDeleteOf course if you want FREE publicity and good looks too, there's always QUEER EYE. And if you don't win the election, at least you got a new look, designer rooms and a cooking lesson.
ReplyDeleteCould we call the show "Queer Eye for the Dissident Guy?"
ReplyDeleteYes, that title would work, and the winner gets to pick a brand new pseudonym for Redhog.
ReplyDeleteThe names Jellyfish, Spinner and BrownNose are not eligible.