Tuesday, May 28, 2019

SPECIAL ED PARENT COMPLAINTS ON THE RISE IN NYC

Thanks to Pat Dobosz for sending out this article from The City showing that there has been a huge increase in parents of special needs students filing complaints that their children have not received special education services they are entitled to.


Complaints filed against the city Department of Education by parents of special education students have skyrocketed since 2014 — sparking a “crisis” that leaves some kids without essential service for months on end, a state-commissioned report found.

The flood of parents battling the public schools system for support is threatening to overwhelm a dispute-resolution system suffering from too few hearing officers and inadequate space to hold hearings, according to the external review obtained by THE CITY.

Complaints jumped 51% between the 2014-’15 and 2017-’18 school years, the report found. That surge has continued into the current school year, with 7,448 complaints filed as of late February — more than the total for the entire prior school year.

The average complaint was open for 202 days in 2017-’18, according to State Education Department data.

Growing complaints have caused a “crisis” that could “render an already fragile hearing system vulnerable to imminent failure and, ultimately, collapse,” Deusdedi Merced, of Special Education Solutions, wrote in a 49-page report obtained through public disclosure law and provided to THE CITY.

“That it has not yet collapsed is remarkable given the staggering numbers of due process complaints filed in New York City.
The article next provides an example of a student who has never had his Individualized Education Plan adhered to in four city schools. This is no surprise.

Special ed neglect is a legacy of former mayor Michael Bloomberg's small schools' policy, at least at the high school level. I have heard from multiple people in different schools that special education services are not sufficient because small schools in general can't possibly provide all of the necessary programs for the students in the small schools that have IEPs that call for varied services. It is also not uncommon from what I have heard to "dump"  special education students into general ed settings with inadequate support.

The City article addresses some of this further down:

“A significant amount of time has been spent trying to get these cases to settlement, so that process can sometimes take six to eight months itself,” said Nelson Mar, a senior staff attorney at Bronx Legal Services.

He noted the root of the problem is that public schools simply don’t have enough services to cover the needs of many of the city’s 224,000 special education students.

New York City logged more due process complaints than California, Florida, Texas and Pennsylvania combined, according to 2016-’17 data collected by the state Education Department.

“The reason why you’re seeing these astronomical numbers is because they have never addressed the fundamental problems with their delivery of special education services,” said Mar. “There’s not enough programs and not enough staff to provide services.”

 Special education is another area where the NYC schools are shortchanging students and parents while putting teachers in impossible situations.

7 comments:

  1. But NYCDOE has hundreds of teachers, social workers, guidance counselors and other staff who are in the infamous atr pool not on staff and vilified by the press in the past now just wasting away. Yet the city will allow for kids to go without their services even though they have the staff to support them.

    The school I am in has two guidance counselors, one social worker in the teachers lounge sitting ducks as atrs. The staff treats them like somehow they are inferior yet these people are highly skilled, experienced educators. Yet the looney 22 year old thinks that the atrs sitting in the teachers lounge are somehow inferior to a 22 year old know nothing. Its truly hysterical and really a shame how poorly run the nycdoe is.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mulgrew says ATR down to only 600, lowest in years. Is he right or wrong?

      Delete
    2. He said the same thing when there was over 2500.

      Delete
  2. Another reason to opt out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mulgrew also says 239 people opted out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wait till June,
      I will bay at moon
      I work so hard
      You old ingrates with Delaney cards
      You’ll see
      When Eva whips you till you pee
      My bank account is overflowing
      While my teacher slaves are a toiling
      Even if I go
      You’ll never know -
      The ease with which I myself am pleased

      Your Beloved President,
      Mike

      Delete
  4. A parent at my school complained and now all ICT classes have two teachers after years of not having the supports. She made things better for all the SWD students.

    More parents should be aware of the child's IEP and regularly check that all services are being provided.

    ReplyDelete

●Comments are moderated.
●Kindly use your Google account. ●Anonymous comments only from Google accounts.
●Please stay on topic and use reputable sources.
●Irrelevant comments will not be posted.
●Try to be respectful; we are professionals.