The annual city budget passed with only 6 dissenting City Councilmembers. 44 voted in favor. There are big budget cuts this year to individual public schools.
Figuring there might be a political price to pay, both Mayor Eric Adams and City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams released statements on the cuts in education (see below).
My guess is that Mayor Adams is not too concerned about Council Education Committee or Oversight Committee hearings. The City Council has little say on the schools in the mayoral control era. The cuts are totally unnecessary and both Adamses know it.
Update: NY 1's Jillian Jorgensen explains why these are real cuts to schools on Twitter (please read tweets from the bottom-up):
First, the Mayor's statement:
Now, the Council Speaker and friends:
Statement from Speaker Adrienne E. Adams, Education Committee Chair Rita Joseph, and Oversight and Investigations Committee Chair Gale Brewer on School Budgets in Fiscal Year 2023
In response to school budgets released last week with significant changes due to lost federal funding and declining enrollment in public schools, Speaker Adrienne Adams, Education Committee Chair Rita Joseph, and Oversight and Investigations Chair Gale Brewer released the following statement.
“Our students are our top priority. That is why we are committing to bringing the full weight of the Council to ensure critical gaps left by lost federal funding and school-specific enrollment are filled when the numbers are updated in September.
“The change in school budgets released last week is the result of one-time federal stimulus funds running out, causing the City to return to its existing school budget formula that it had suspended because of thesethese pandemic-related federal funds. As the number of students in our public schools declined by 120,000 students, the impact on some schools became deeply concerning. While schools with increased enrollment received proposed school budgets with funding increases due to the formula, other schools received lower proposed budgets without the stop-gap of federal funding that could lead to the loss of important services. Our focus must be on equity, ensuring schools and students who have historically been underserved are prioritized.
“This Council will be pursuing every avenue available to address this issue of lost federal funding. First, the City has already allocated over $700 million more in city funds for schools within this budget compared to the current fiscal year. Second, we will work at the local level with Council Members to better understand the specific impacts on individual schools in their districts. Third, the Council will hold a joint oversight hearing with the Committee on Oversight & Investigations and the Committee on Education to identify and scrutinize every dollar of federal stimulus received or expected to be received by our city that could fill certain gaps of lost federal funding for our schools. And fourth, we will push the Department of Education to prioritize funding within its more than $30 billion budget to meet the specific needs identified for individual schools, shifting money from bloated areas of its central operations to classrooms and student supports.
Our students must be our priority, and we will leave no stone unturned to protect them by ensuring we work with our education stakeholders, scrutinize every federal dollar, and push for Mayor Adams and the Department of Education to fulfill its promise to the students and families that rely on our school system.”
BACKGROUND:
Investing in Education and Youth
In the Fiscal Year 2023 budget, the Council secured major investments in education and youth programs, in addition to the more than $700 million increase in city funds committed to public schools.
- $277 million for the Summer Rising Program to provide free academic enrichment to students.
- $79+ million to expand Summer Youth Employment Program to a record-level 100,000 slots (baselined).
- $46 million to provide increased and fair wages for Special Education Pre-K and Day Care Providers to support the success of these critical programs that serve our youth.
- $33.4 million to expand Career and Technical Education.
- $30 million for Fair Futures program that serves young people who go through the foster care system.
- $19.7 million to double the slots for Work Learn Grow double the number of year-round youth employment to 4,400 jobs.
- $14 million to restore Community Schools funding and add funding to support new schools.
- $11.2 million to provide additional supports to English Language Learners.
- $10 million towards childcare for Undocumented Families.
- $10 million to advance the Education Equity Action Plan to implement citywide kindergarten-to-high school Black studies curriculum.
- $9.2 million to support the Low-Income Childcare Voucher program.
- $5.1 million for DOE Community Coordinators to support unhoused and immigrant students.
- $4.4 million for CUNY Reconnect pilot program to help working-age adults attain a degree that expands earning potential – at all CUNY campuses, serving 10,000 students in its first year.⁸
When does the reorganization sheet have to be out for elementary school.
ReplyDeletewith our current budget, we will have to put 38 kids in each class
ReplyDeleteElementary school teachers should:
ReplyDeleteComplete preference sheets early in the spring.
Be notified of their teaching assignments for the following year no later than 10 school days before the end of the term.
"Raises? We don't need no stinkin' raises!"
ReplyDeleteGive us the buyout that the stimulus money sank last year
ReplyDeleteThe pendulum is swinging…
ReplyDeleteTX-34 is an 85% Hispanic majority district. It went from D +14 to R +8 (22 point swing) within two years. Dems should be past the point of sweating. This is full panic territory now.
The criminal mismanagement of the schools continues under mayoral control. Putin would be proud.
ReplyDeleteJames, et al.,
ReplyDeleteA buyout/early retirement incentive would be great for many, but has the state ever taken that route during a teacher shortage?
Regards to all.
Retail spending fell in May, amid high inflation, rising interest rates and weakening consumer confidence.
ReplyDeleteDon't worry, we good. Raises ae upcoming.
Those dues have been put to good use.
With a looming recession, the rise of remote, and the increase in urban crime I think we will see a continued flood of people to the suburbs.
ReplyDeleteAlready almost all of my friends have left the cities.
They don't think it's worth it - the costs, the schools, the lack of space...
We may ALREADY be in a recession.
And, if not, we're darn close to one.
Atlanta Fed revised its second quarter GDP estimate down to .9% growth. By the time the final number is revealed, we may learn that the second quarter was NEGATIVE growth just like the first.
At least Mulgrew is about to be a master negotiator.
Contract meeting today. If anybody is on the committee we need info on how it went. Yes, I know folks can't share details but they can let us know the general tone/feeling of how things went. Please share!
ReplyDeleteThere it is: Atlanta Fed Q2 GDP tracker: 0.0%.
ReplyDeleteWe are effectively in a technical recession.
LEts not forget about the looming food shortage...Can anyone say SPAM
ReplyDeleteSo much wasted money all over the dems are like rich idiot impulsive shoppers waste so much like 50 billion we gave ukraine that people somehow support.
ReplyDeleteWhy haven't we invested in building 3-5 new schools on every borough in the last 6 years with rise of immigrants and students in the city?
Even more than a 20 year buyout we need 20 year guaranteed 40% pension. You can have a buyout with little to no pension.
I hear city wants 4-6 year plan on raises city 2-3 years. Be looking at 6% over 3 yars if lucky to get meager 2% raise.
159. And the 95 billion in corporate welfare that both of our two big right wing parties give to the capitalists which people somehow support.
Deletewhy haven't we invested in social housing with the continuous rise of unhoused persons?
could it be the class based system you support doesn't allow wealth to flow into the pockets of working class people?
For NY teachers we might have to do without the filet mignon but for many Americans it means less food on the dinner table. One of the benefits of being raised by immigrants was being taught how to make the less desirable cuts of meat delicious and how to grow some vegetables. American born are spoiled. Time for all Americans to embrace their roots. Your ancestors knew how to survive. And it’s what unites us. Whether we’re the descendants of immigrants or American slaves, we have a lot to learn from their ability to make it through tough times all on their own.
ReplyDeleteElementary school teachers should:
ReplyDeleteComplete preference sheets early in the spring.
Be notified of their teaching assignments for the following year no later than 10 school days before the end of the term.
ISN'T TODAY 10 school days before the term end in Elementary? STILL NO REORG sheet.
Retirement Incentive time. Get rid of us top salaried people.
ReplyDeleteAnd what's this on the horizon: the city's health plan for its workers is being eyed for a downgrade i mean a change. Working class folks will always bear the brunt because we refuse to stand TOGETHER. We're focusing on dem/Republic while they both work us over. Anon2323 is right about building new schools but what's the point if some people are still going to "pass all". Yes many of our parents were resilient. What's the old rhyme about trying to make a dollar out of 15 cents. Hopefully working people will figure out how to stand together.
ReplyDeleteDon't encourage our very corrupt politicians to give meager 2% raises
ReplyDeletewhile inflation rages at above 8%. Demand that you get big raises which you deserve. Don't fall for the NY city game of fake austerity and budget cuts to deny the working middle class fair wage increases.
Too many teachers have low self esteem and do not understand how severely their human rights are violated by NY state law. NY state labor law is a violation of human rights. It denies you the dignity to strike to express your work related demands. Every day you work for NY city and can not strike because of the Taylor Law your
human rights are violated.
The United States is not a leader or role model in human rights. The United States violates the human rights of its citizens in the area of its labor laws.
Do not fall for the lazy thinking and meager increases that your UFT leaders encourage for your salary and contract negotiations. Anything less than making up for the 15% plus loss of pay due to inflation is lazy cowardly thinking.
My school did not give out reorganization sheets and blatantly said it won’t be done yet. Union knows and is waiting till next week to address!! What are the ramifications. Principals don’t care they give some excuse and do what they want. My principal is also making us come in the last day of school when most of the city is REMOTE. Principals who do what they want just because they can. Just horrible
ReplyDeleteWhat’s your email? I need to send you a guest blog post submission. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteDavid Suker
Teachertrouble@aol.com
8:50,
ReplyDeleteDo you realize how hard it is to go to suburban schools? Unless your have a real in(or an uncle who is one of ten 18 asst superintendents in each district, you have no shot).
Don’t buy that myth.
Young people are leaving bc of tier 6. Who wants to do this job for 40 plus years?
I’m in my 40’s and would leave if I couldn’t get out at 55 and leave this cesspool of a state.
6:01, sounds like MY d75 school in the BX. Union rep (quasi admin) isn't pushing for the organization sheet. Have to come in for team building on the 28th... Nice when the administration has the union rep in the pocket.
ReplyDeleteAny word on how the negotiation meeting went yesterday? We gotta know!
ReplyDeleteThe USA is so abusive blah blah blah. That’s why so many people want to be here. So much so they risk their lives to cross the Rio Grand. There’s a bunch of Canadians that want to be here too. I can’t wait until you lefties get trounced in November. “The unhoused”? You mean the homeless. Who convinced you “unhoused” signals virtue? The same idiots who convinced you that Ukrainian Nazis are worth fighting for? The same idiots who convinced you there are 89 genders? We could help those down on their luck to find housing but we can’t because lefty morons think the drug addicted schizophrenic who refuses medical treatment and rehab and who throws his feces at commuters on a train is just as deserving as the lady with 3 kids who works at McDonalds. Your ideas are stupid and thank heavens more and more Americans are seeing just how insane the left is.
ReplyDelete600,000 unhoused persons in the United States that we know about. certainly many more that aren't accounted for. no matter the condition they are in, they deserve shelter and care. if a criminal act does occur, then of course you punish criminal acts. ironically, that is one way to gain shelter here, become jailed.
Delete11:33 there are around 9 million documented US expats living abroad. people move around for many reasons.
DeleteReactionaries like anon 11:33 go after terms when they are unwilling to do anything about material conditions. Your focus on a term is a choice being made over a focus on the homeless crisis. It is also a generational situation. The term unhoused has become more popular in the past decade for younger people within housing/homeless organizations. The people that put in the work to fight for the homeless are aware of this change in dialogue. No one freaks out over it except the reactionaries that fear social programs.
DeleteJust a few years back, we had created the best economy for American workers in a generation. Low inflation, robust growth, record low unemployment. Democrats’ recklessness has produced soaring inflation, slowing growth, and growing risk of a full-on recession.
ReplyDeleteIf you are young and not tied to NYC, your best bet is get on-line and see which cities or areas in the US are in need of license teachers in your subject area. Some districts are willing to pay for you to relocate because they are so desperate for teachers. The pay won't be as good but taxes and rent will be a lot cheaper so it's all relative.
ReplyDeleteStock market down to 2020 levels. Sounds good for people who get 1% raises with 10% inflation.
ReplyDelete10% inflation?
ReplyDeleteY'all crunch y'alls actual #s?
My "lived experience" is 20+%.
Did I do that right? ;)
Not freaking out, 5:38. Just pointing out how stupid it is to switch names for absolutely no reason other than over educated elitists think it signals virtue. It doesn’t. What social programs? Open air drug markets? If the mentally ill need help, I’m all for it. If drug addicts need rehab, I’m all for it. What reasonable people don’t want is whatever the hell progressives have done to San Francisco, NYC, Austin. Addicts and the insane who refuse help cannot be allowed to create tent cities and continue to behave badly. Kids should be able to play in a park without needles and human shit. But hey, I don’t live in those places so if it’s what the residents who live there want, it’s their business. None of it would fly where I live.
ReplyDelete612. Social Housing.
DeleteDawkins Just curious, where are you hearing there is a teacher shortage? I was told by a new teacher looking for a job that no one is hiring. In any case it is economics. They can hire almost two teachers for the pay of one at top salary. The one that passed last year only didn't go through in the city because they got all the covid money that is running out. Sleepy joe is putting us right back into financial crisis again so I have a very slim hope they could revive it.
ReplyDelete7:53-- thanks for your post. There has been some chatter about shortages as a result of COVID protocols, especially subs, in conjunction with recent economic woes. I just grabbed these 3 quick articles as a reference.
ReplyDeletewww.ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/ap-top-news/2021/09/22/covid-19-creates-dire-us-shortage-of-teachers-school-staff
www.chalkbeat.org/2022/5/19/23130876/student-absences-teacher-shortages-pandemic-lessons
www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-59687947
There are others from Reuters and other reliable sites.
Regards and have a good weekend.