These tweets came from the CTU:
This strike would not be legal.
The Official Blog of the Independent Community of Educators, a caucus of the United Federation of Teachers
Please refer to this update and not prior versions of Personnel Memorandum NO. 1. Follow it to the letter.
Please watch the CNN interview with Mayor Eric Adams from this morning and judge for yourself where Michael Mulgrew and Eric Adams are coming from. Thanks to Shelley for sending it to us.
This information is from WBEZ in Chicago:
The Chicago Teachers Union is setting the stage for all teachers and other members to refuse to work in-person beginning Wednesday in conditions they deem unsafe.
The union has scheduled a vote for its more than 25,000 members on Tuesday during the day, asking if they support refusing to work in-person starting Wednesday but to work virtually instead. Tuesday’s vote will be followed by a vote that afternoon by the union’s elected House of Delegates on the refusal action.
At a CTU virtual town hall Sunday evening, 80% of the 8,000 members on the call said they did not want to work in-person in Chicago Public Schools classrooms under current conditions, according to CTU members at the event. CPS classes resumed Monday after a two-week break amid the largest COVID-19 surge yet.
CPS teachers can only work remotely if it’s sanctioned by the Chicago Board of Education. And in an email to families Sunday evening, CPS CEO Pedro Martinez said he stands “firmly behind the decision to protect our student’s physical and mental health and promote their academic progress by keeping CPS schools safely open for in-person learning.”
This action is triggering a showdown between the union and the school district, which could lock teachers out of their remote classrooms and prevent them from teaching. This would effectively shut down the school district.
Mayor Lori Lightfoot on Monday made clear where she stands.
“What we have learned from this pandemic is that schools are the safest place for students to be: we have spent over a $100 million to put mitigations in place, most CPS staff members are vaccinated, and we generally see little transmission in school settings,” she said in a statement. “Keeping kids safely in school where they can learn and thrive is what we should all be focused on.” Lightfoot also stressed the academic and emotional damage impact of remote learning.
This is what real unions do. They listen to their members. Meanwhile back in NYC, UFT President Michael Mulgrew's strategy looks as if it is to grovel to the new Mayor which will basically get us nowhere but an opposition caucus leader has filed a lawsuit to get the system to go remote.
We have news from Lydia A:
Case Update:
1. Corporation Counsel, representing NYC and the NYC DOE, has been assigned case.
2. CC called me on my prep to politely say, "I was assigned your case. By the way, the City says your case is meritless."
3. I told him, "I'm really not surprised you would say this but ok."
4. NY Post called me and said that they couldn't find my papers in the court system.
5. I called the Ex Parte Office and had this long back and forth conversation to find out that my case was assigned to a judge who is currently out on vacation!!!!! Thankfully I was able to convince the clerk to reassign my case.
We understand a judge has been assigned and the City is taking this seriously as they have already completed their response to the Article 78. You can sign a letter to the judge by clicking here. Lydia informed me this evening that 4,000 have signed on.
As for the United for Change, Presidential candidate Camille Eterno was interviewed on CBS News nationally.
Here is the soundbite quote they used:
Educators like Camille Eterno, a high school English teacher, are urging the mayor to listen.
"I recognize the need for students to be present in the buildings, but I'm also cognizant of the fact that if we're all bunched up together and we get sick, we're not going to be there anyway," said Eterno, who's been teaching for 24 years.
Someone sent out the CDC guidelines for isolating in schools for staff and students. Follow them. 10 days of isolation for students and staff who have symptoms or test positive. This includes those who are fully vaccinated.
CDC has updated isolation and quarantine recommendations for the public. These recommendations do not apply to healthcare personnel and do not supersede state, local, tribal, or territorial laws, rules, and regulations. Read CDC’s media statement.
Isolation is separating people who have COVID-19 or symptoms of COVID-19 from those who are not infected or showing symptoms in order to prevent transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.You isolate when you show symptoms of COVID-19 or are infected with the virus that causes COVID-19, even if you don’t have symptoms.Isolation is different from quarantine. Quarantine is used by someone who has been exposed to the virus that causes COVID-19 but has not tested positive for COVID-19 and does not have symptoms. Quarantine is important because even before a person has tested positive for COVID-19 or has symptoms, they could spread the virus that causes COVID-19 to other people without knowing. Quarantine is used to prevent transmission of the virus by ensuring that unvaccinated people who have been in close contact with someone with COVID-19 stay apart from others. If people have symptoms and/or have a positive viral test for COVID-19 while in quarantine, they should immediately begin the process for isolation.
People who are confirmed to have COVID-19 or are showing symptoms of COVID-19 need to isolate. This includes people who are not fully vaccinated and fully vaccinated people. More specifically,
People can spread the virus that causes COVID-19 for a full 10 days from when they develop symptoms, even if they are feeling better. People who have tested positive, but do not have symptoms may spread the virus before they have symptoms or even spread the virus if they never have symptoms at all. For this reason, isolation should last at least 10 days. Day 0 is the day symptoms began or the day the person took a test that had a positive result. Day 1 is the day after symptoms began or, if a person does not have symptoms, the day after the person tested positive (use the date the test was collected).
Dear _______,
Omicron has had a major impact on our city this holiday, and many of us New Yorkers have already struggled with this variant. We advised the new mayor that it would be safest to allow our school system to go remote temporarily until we could get a handle on the staffing challenges that each school is about to face as we return. However, he feels strongly that schools need to remain open.
We are determined to do everything in our power to keep our school communities safe when schools are open, and our work with the city and the DOE over the break has resulted in more expansive testing protocols and other new safety measures. Here are the final details that we were able to work out now that the new administration has taken office.
|
|
|
|
|
The email below was sent to UFT President Michael Mulgrew on Friday. No reply as of now from the President. The positivity rate is now over 30% as of Sunday.
When the pandemic began you used to talk about your three Pillars, and safety was one of them. Last week I was telling friends and colleagues that I felt like my school was swimming in covid. I tested positive on the 29th. Look I hope omicron isn’t so bad, data from South Africa shows that. The only thing is, in South Africa kids are on summer vacation, and here school is in session. We have more cases than ever before, and no baseline testing after break. You would say safety is important, we have our own medical experts. So do they really say that the plan is safe with 28,000 new cases in NYC yesterday?
I mean I get it, I’m not a fool. Keep kids in school no matter what. But if parents don’t feel safe doing it, teachers don’t feel safe, don’t you and the union lose all credibility?
We used to close schools for 3% positivity. Now we have 25% positivity, you can have covid and you still go in. Safety is not a part of the plan anymore.
I know it’s tough. Eric Adams is the new mayor. And the last thing you want to do is come out and close school. But, and here’s the thing, the current plan is insane.
Everyone gets covid is the current plan. And maybe that works for most people, and maybe it’ll be just a cold for most, but when everyone in the city gets it that’s a bad thing.
Okay that’s what I wanted to say. Maybe this will change some minds, though probably not. Unions should fight for safe working conditions. Right? Isn’t that the main reason we have one?
Thanks,
Mike Muntner
Covid Positive Chapter leader at Nest +m
--
Adam wrote to UFT President Michael Mulgrew and then Chancellor Meisha Porter before the break and we printed it here. It was very well received by our audience. Adam strikes again. Enjoy.
Great (Un)Expectations!
What should the nearly 1.3 million staff and students anticipate, when classes resume in NYC, on January 3rd? Very few parents, students and staff truly feel safe or comfortable going back to their school. The reason, simply put, is that the DoE has consistently mismanaged the handling of Covid cases. They opened the schools in September with massively overcrowded buildings, and a crackerjack plan that consisted of opening windows, using some air filters and wearing masks. Now, the DoE has provided limited assurances that our schools will be safe when it comes to accurately reporting the true number of Covid cases. The track record for this bureaucracy’s handling of Covid is paltry. Essentially, the DoE has basically been embarrassed and pressured into enacting a questionable safety plan, moving forward.
I know that the DoE put out a plan, but I can’t help to wonder how effective is their seemingly reactive engagement to Covid. Why do they feign shock that a viral pandemic has overwhelmed an already fragile and poorly run school system? And how dare they tout a plan that is already a fortnight too late? Ask anybody who has ever worked for the NYC Department of Education, how reliable is the quality level of craftsmanship of anything the DoE purchases. They find three bidders and pick the cheapest. Implementing that same logic with a home Covid test kit is the textbook definition of negligence. Is there any parent or staff member who actually believes that the DoE is suddenly going to procure over two million high quality test kits, in less than a week? With that said, since schools are not closing, wouldn’t it be easier and smarter to just test everyone while they are in the building? Then, everything will get reported under one streamlined agency. The logistics will initially prove challenging to set up, but once it is fully implemented the system will be much more manageable and organized. However, yet again, this would entail a pro-active approach to problem-solving.
It is also quite deplorable that the DoE and UFT now agree that the Situation Room has to be adequately staffed. Where was the rage that this central hub to report and monitor Covid was understaffed. I heard whispers from the union, but no outrage; no frustration, just an acknowledgment that the Situation Room lacked staff. How many DoE employees will actually be manning the Situation Room, because if you double or triple a trickle, you still only have a weak stream. At my school, when nearly 50 people a day were calling out (not all positive, thankfully) and hundreds of students were being kept home, the Situation Room only had us with single-digit Covid confirmations. Add to that, they didn’t answer the phones nor would they call back administrators trying to report active, confirmed Covid cases. Such gross mismanagement, by a joint city agency, should warrant a federal investigation of Bill de Blasio. And now we should just trust the DoE, because they are saying we really fixed it this time. Here’s an example of how the DoE fixes things, look at their new slogan, Stay Open, Stay Safe! Really? Shouldn’t this have been the mantra since before September, not mid-debacle December?
Let’s consider what else they are going to do to keep the students and staff safe. Doubling the testing in all schools sounds great, but now we go from 1.5% to a whopping 3%. School staff are on the front lines and their personal safety, up until a few days ago, did not seem to matter. As for the students, who are very vulnerable to Omicron, they seem to matter even less. Countless schools finished December, running on fumes. The sheer number of staff out, was overwhelming. Classes were collapsed and staff were offered massive overtime to cover all of the absent teachers. In the end, the kids got cheated out of instruction, and again the DoE was completely clueless. Where was the UFT, even in mid-November? They were certainly not screaming from every school building, calling for universal testing. If anything, they were complicit with the 10% staff testing threshold set by the DoE, back in early December.
My angst with UFT and DoE leadership is predicated upon their hubris directed towards the rank and file; a disregard for the students, and a consistently flawed decision-making process when it comes to safety and educational policies. My umbrage with the UFT, should not be misconstrued as misguided union animus. If anything, I think that a teachers union is the most important form of organized labor in this country. I just refuse to accept dysfunctional leadership in times of true crisis.
If you have never worked in a NYC public school, then please think twice before you attack school staff who are simply asking for all precautions and plans to be in place. That type of basic safety has not happened yet, not even close. If anything, we should want the highest level of safety measures in place so kids can learn and everyone can go home without the fear of spreading Covid like some Haight-Ashbury viral free-for-all.
Sincerely,
Adam C Bergstein
Happy New Year!
United for Change is hitting the ground running. The group is serious about building a better Union. Get to know the top officer candidates on Zoom Sunday at 4:00 p.m.
Michael Mulgrew's latest email is below. Please read it closely. Mulgrew is on board with a new DOE health screener that threatens legal action against staff, parents, and even students. Are they planning on going after my 7 year old son if he sneezes at school for lying on the health screening or am I going to jail?
The UFT's position is basically to keep schools fully open at all costs and just hope for the best with a few mitigations. If you think I'm misrepresenting the Union's view, besides reading Mulgrew's email, check out this comment on the NYC Teachers and other UFT Members Only Facebook page from Brian Gibbons, an Assistant to President Mulgrew:
Now take a look at this pinned Tweet from Gibbons, since removed, that a teacher sent us:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yesterday, a candidate for United for Change, Lydia A, filed an Article 78 proceeding in NYC Civil Court protesting the reopening of NYC schools without adequate testing, mitigation measures, and allowing for a pivot of instruction to remote for January 3 to January 18, 2022. We have submitted the legal documents- a petition, a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO), an affidavit, an Order to Show Cause (OSC), and a Request for Judicial Intervention (RJI)- and we are waiting for a judge to be assigned to our case.
Newark, NJ is another district going fully remote for January.
Eventually, the pressure will start to build on the new mayor of NYC to move to full remote instruction.
I still can't understand why the UFT is not loudly leading the charge for safety. The UFT is letting down its members as usual while many within the opposition to Michael Mulgrew's Unity Caucus are fighting by planning actions and filing a lawsuit for remote instruction.
Newark schools will switch to fully remote learning after the holiday recess ends Jan. 3 and keep students home for at least two weeks as COVID cases continue to climb in the city, officials said Thursday evening.
Superintendent Roger León said the district made the decision after consulting with the city health department about the recent surge in infections. Students were told to prepare for the possibility of remote learning before leaving for winter break and are expected to return to classrooms on Jan. 18.
“This is not the news I want to be sharing with students and their families at this time because we need to continue in-person instruction,” León said in a statement, “but the health and safety of students and staff remains the top priority.”
Newark became the largest school district in New Jersey to announce the shift to a fully remote plan for students, a consequential decision likely to affect attendance, learning loss, and student mental health. It joins several other districts that recently decided to revert to at-home learning, including Paterson, East Orange, and Jersey City.
UFT Solidarity and United for Change Executive Board candidate Lydia A is not waiting around to see what the UFT does with the omicron surge now up to close to half a million US cases in one day on Wednesday. Lydia was in Manhattan today filing an Article 78 court case against the City-Department of Education to get remote teaching from January 3, 2022 through January 18, 2022.
Here is the Order to Show Cause she is asking the judge to sign:
We hope to have more soon as this story develops.
When was the last time the UFT polled its members? CTU shows the way on how a union should react to a crisis: Find out where the membership is at and what they are collectively willing to do.
A NYC reaction:
Update: We have the CTU poll results.
Michael Mulgrew's latest email is below. Mulgrew states: "But we won't stop pushing until we are confident that this new plan has been implemented fully by Jan. 3." In all likelihood it won't be fully implemented and then what does Mulgrew intend to do? You know the answer.
Dear _______,
Last week we told the city to fix its safety system for schools that was undeniably broken before the break. Mayor de Blasio and Mayor-elect Adams held a press conference today announcing their new slogan for our schools — stay open, stay safe. That’s a great thing to say, but if we want to stay open and safe, the city has to do the work to make that happen.
Governor Hochul has provided New York City public schools with two million at-home rapid tests, and today Bill de Blasio and Eric Adams announced new elements of a safety plan designed to meet the challenges of this new phase of the pandemic. But we won't stop pushing until we are confident that this new plan has been implemented fully by Jan. 3.
De Blasio and Adams announced three changes that, if implemented correctly, will be a promising improvement to our school system’s safety program:
The staff of the Situation Room will double in size, making it bigger than ever before and able to handle the current surge.
The city will double in-school PCR testing in every school every week. These tests will now include both vaccinated and unvaccinated students as well as staff. The city will make another push to get parents to consent for their child to be tested regardless of vaccination status.
Close contacts and classmates of positive cases will now have immediate access to two at-home rapid tests that they can take to monitor themselves for the days after exposure.
City officials also told us that every school staff member will get a testing kit containing two tests, and more testing kits will be available for them as needed.
Thanks to all of us working together to tell the city we will not accept unsafe schools, our city and state leaders have started to address the myriad issues that we identified. We, as educators, are always prepared to do our jobs. The real issue is whether the city can do its job — ensuring that ample testing is available in every school and an improved Situation Room is actually in place by next week.
We are moving closer to a safe reopening of schools. But we are not there yet. We will continue to work through this week to advocate for you and our school communities and will update you on all the details of the new safety program before Jan. 3.
Stay safe.
Sincerely,
Michael Mulgrew
UFT President
New York City launched a new anti-coronavirus (COVID-19) program that officials said will help schools stay safe, so that they can stay open.
When schools resume on Monday, Department of Education (DOE) facilities will see double the PCR testing, and a new effort utilizing take-home tests that Mayor Bill de Blasio said would help keep the city’s students safe.
“This is how we’re going to look at schools from this point on — keep them safe and keep them open,” de Blasio said. “We have a lot of evidence now that’s told us this is the approach that’s going to work for the future."
Whenever there’s a positive case in a classroom, each child will take home two at-home test kits over the course of seven days. Those who test negative and are asymptomatic can go back to school causing less disruption to their education, de Blasio said.
An increased state and federal supply of take-home test kits allowed the city to launch the new program, the outgoing mayor said.
Compared to what was previously available, two times the PCR tests will be available each week in every school throughout the city for vaccinated and unvaccinated students along with staff, who de Blasio said have a 96% vaccination rate.
There will be no tests before schools reopen, because the mayor said he wants to ensure a smooth transition back to operation.
Gov. Kathy Hochul and Mayor-elect Eric Adams, who will be in office when the new programs are put inplace, joined de Blasio to support the announcement.
“We spent $11 trillion fighting COVID. It is time for us to realize that this is a resilient city and a resilient country,” Adams said. “We must reopen our city and we can do that.”
Teachers are already reacting.
From twitter:
This came our way this evening. Please take the UFT Solidarity survey on COVID testing.
Testing in NYC Public Schools- A Survey by UFT Solidarity (with the support of folks in the UFC Coalition)
Per an email sent out by UFT President Mulgrew on December 2, "the city will now allow the testing of school staff on a voluntary basis. Beginning on Monday, Dec. 6, school staff can request to be tested on their school’s scheduled test day.
"According to the new policy:
1. Student testing must be completed before any adults can be tested.
2. Test providers must maintain their schedule and may not extend their time at the school to accommodate staff who want to be tested.
3. Test providers may test up to 10% of staff.
4. All COVID-19 testing of DOE staff is voluntary, but staff must give consent via the DOE’s daily health screening form. It may take up to five days for the DOE to process your consent so please submit it as soon as possible."
We have been hearing troubling reports from schools. Some staff have not been informed of what days testing is scheduled to arrive at school. In other schools, we are hearing of staff members being turned away.
What is happening in your school?
Remember, we keep each other safe.
This information will only be shared with a small group of people so including your name and email is optional.
From Republican President Donald J Trump:
We have bipartisan passing the buck, or rather, bipartisan failure.
Yesterday, my kids and I were continuing our last-second Christmas shopping tradition. We bought a whole load of gifts from Target online and did their curbside pickup in Westbury. It was all good.
We then headed for home in Queens in our 2018 Toyota Camry Hybrid and the car literally went dead on the Meadowbrook Parkway. It looks like it was a fuel pump problem that the car was recalled for that we never had a problem with before the recall. We brought it in and Toyota replaced the fuel pump two weeks ago and now this. It's kind of scary when the car dies at 55 MPH on the highway and then displays a dashboard message to visit the dealerhip. No kidding.
We managed to get to the shoulder safely and the car restarted once so we were able to get off the highway and onto the middle of Old Country Road where the engine went bye-bye for good.
I called the local Nassau police. A car came within ten minutes and the officer helped my kids get safely to the sidewalk to wait and then he worked with me to push the car off the road and into a parking lot. He then offered to drive us home but by that time my wife was on the way to rescue us. Thanks to the Nassau Police for the professional service.
As for the American Automobile Association, they must be short-staffed for December 24 as they took three hours to come for a tow so our kids got their dream Christmas Eve dinner: Mcdonalds.
Toyota will be hearing from us next week for sure for botching up the recalled fuel pump repair that left me stuck on Christmas Eve but for now I am happy to be home enjoying Christmas with family.
Be safe everyone as we are setting COVID case records in NY. Hospitalizations and deaths are lagging indicators so don't tell me how they are still relatively low. I hope and pray they stay low.
Merry Christmas to all!
Update: Toyota took the car in on Monday and it was a minor fix. I am going to give it a good ride today to test it.
As UFters head into vacation, I saw this tonight on Facebook and thought it was appropriate. It is from Sara Nelson, the President of the Association of Flight Attendants, CWA.
In NYC public schools, we can add UFT management to our employer telling us we are lucky to have a job.
To the commenter who called me a dreamer, Sara's vision for the future of labor is what I dream about and have been working for since I became an activist in 1994 and continue doing. Here is a little of Sara's bio:
The New York Times called her "America's most powerful flight attendant" for her role in helping to end the 35-day Government Shutdown and InStyle Magazine placed her on their Top 50 Badass Women list.
2022 is the year where enough UFters are going to come together to start turning Sara's vision into reality for NYC teachers and other UFT members.