Tuesday, February 21, 2017


Over at the Pen is Mightier than the Person blog, Sullio has done a take-down of NYSUT Executive Vice President and now Presidential candidate Andy Pallotta that is too good to miss. He then endorses Mike Lillis and the Stronger Together officers for the top positions at NYSUT..

Here is some of Sullio's knockout of Pallotta.

Evidently, Pallotta is finally serious about reviving NYSUT, and thinks he's got what it takes to lead public education to the promised land. His eight-year record as a NYSUT officer, however, belies any serious hope that Pallotta can help pull schools back from the brink.

As NYSUT Executive Vice President, Pallotta's main charge has been to lobby legislators on behalf of working teachers, and at least earn a legitimate victory every once and a while.    

Since 2009, however, New York teachers have faced loss after loss, with Governor Andy Cuomo and the state legislator callously attacking teacher pensions and due process rights while spewing Common Core tests across the state. Thanks to Cuomo's Education Transformation Act, for example, trumped-up charges are now all it takes to fire tenured teachers and hand their schools off to voucher school villains. Meanwhile, s
uburban and rural districts are pinned-down by an insolvency-inducing tax cap, while urban schools are flush with rats instead of cash. 

But it's not like Pallotta hasn't tried. In fact, just last year he spent $109,600 (the maximum amount) of voluntary member donations (VOTE-COPE) on Republicans in the New York Senate, whose leader - John Flanagan - recently pledged allegiance to Betsy DeVos, President Trump's toxic secretary of education. It's safe to say that whatever campaign cash Flanagan and his flunkies received from NYSUT was spent on obliterating any compassion they had left for public education - the platform of American democracy.    

Speaking of President Trump, Pallotta is a former member of the United Federation of Teachers (UFT), which recently took the absurd action of striking any references to Trump from a union resolution, opting to refer to Trump only as "the presidential election." Pallotta's pals in the UFT were apparently too afraid to offend public school teachers who voted for Trump, otherwise known as Those Who Should Know Better. 

And it's this kind of kowtowing that's placed teachers and their unions exactly where they are today - begging for scraps at the laps of people whose names they won't even whisper.

This is America, and our freedoms should include permission to criticize our leaders. Any educator who delays speaking truth to power is only running toward the inevitable cries of "Would've, could've, should've!" as their careers careen into flames.

Next, Sullio gives Mike Lillis and his Stronger Together's team a robust endorsement. 

A high School physics teacher and current President of the Lakeland Federation of Teachers (LFT), Mike Lillis has experience which Andy Pallotta severely lacks - running a classroom while running a union in the dark age of school deform. Lillis also has a good-old fashioned obsession with facts and data, which he has used to help unravel and reveal the fleecing of public education.

The attacks on schools can be boiled down to one number - 1630 - which equals the average score New York State expects students to achieve on the SAT. Only 34% of students who take the SAT, however, achieve this score, and your third-grader will not be one of them unless she scores a 3 on tests Cuomo himself once called "meaningless." Subpar students naturally means subpar teachers, whose subpar schools will soon be transformed into subpar websites.     

In a world of alternative facts, 1630 is an indisputable digit which represents all that is wrong with school deform.

Sadly, when Lillis brought this bogus benchmark before the New York State Education Department (NYSED) and Commissioner MaryEllen Elia, crickets filled the room. After all, everyone had always assumed that "college and career ready" meant whatever Bill Gates wanted it to mean, and did not originate from say, some arbitrary test score. NYSED promised to "get back to" Lillis with an explanation, and he's still waiting. Lillis did get the Commissioner to admit that the teacher evaluation system was "random", however, a both hilarious and horrifying admission from the state's top education official.

Joining Lillis on the ST slate of candidates are Bianca Tanis, who's running for Pallotta's old position, Megan DeLaRosa (1st Vice President), and Nate Hathaway (Secretary/Treasurer). Like Lillis, all of them are full-time teachers and unionists, and all of them care deeply about their profession, on personal and professional levels.

Fearsome Foursome (clockwise from top left): Lillis, Tanis, Hathaway, DeLaRosa

All of them are also leaders of the opt-out movement, an unprecedented act of civil disobedience which has pushed back against the privatization of public education. As a founder of New York State Allies for Public Education (NYSAPE), Bianca Tanis has traveled the state and appeared on national television to educate teachers and parents on the standardized threats their schools face. This dedication alone has given working teachers more hope than Andy Pallotta could ever hope to give.      

Even amid the lunacy of a Trump presidency, t
he existential threats faced by NYSUT and teachers in general cannot be minimized. This election should at least help expose those threats to a public flogging of logic and the altruism of educators. 

Lillis and ST recognize these threats, and want schools to persevere and prosper. They know, for instance, that the eager students sitting in their classrooms today are a lot less likely to become teachers tomorrow because of the losses of the past decade, losses which the likes of Pallotta have done little to stop.  

With all three branches of government ready to turn America into a Right to Work nation, it's finally time for NYSUT to get serious and give grassroots teachers a chance to lead. Besides, there's little to stop NYSUT from sliding off the cliff once dues becomes optional, and your leader will be the guy who brought you Tier VI and four-year tenure.

Mike Lillis and the ST slate will fight for fairness, for all teachers and students. They understand the importance of the Union movement and do not enjoy seeing it decimated by apathy and ignorance.

Whether it's ST, the UFT, or NYSUT, the Union must endure - it is the only barrier keeping us from the billionaire barbarians.

We must hold the line and move forward, together.  

I hope Sullio's piece has a hand in convincing people sitting on the fence that we were right to endorse Lillis here at the ICE-UFT blog.


Anonymous said...

A 15-year-old boy survived being shot in the eye during a broad-daylight confrontation in Brooklyn Monday afternoon, police sources said.

A gunman blasted both the teen and a second victim, an 18-year-old man who was struck in the leg, after an argument at about 2:35 p.m. on E. 55th St., near Lenox Road, in East Flatbush. Both victims are expected to survive.

“I saw him on a stretcher,” Belinda Harris, 45, said of the teen, whom she recognized from the neighborhood.

“His eyes were closed and he was bleeding profusely from his head from the right side. He was not talking, he was not moving.”
I guess kids get bored when they are off from school.
Police are looking for the gunman, who fled the scene in a gray four-door sedan driving north on E. 55th St., sources said.

Sources said the gunman got out of the sedan and opened fire, though it wasn’t immediately clear whom he was targeting.

The teen was taken by EMS to Brookdale Hospital. The older victim was taken to Kings County Hospital.

Cops recovered four shell casings from the scene.

Anonymous said...

NYSUT? Don't really care about them right now. Way more concerned with the fact that I and the teachers at my school are going to be facing 4 evaluations next year when the rest of the state is getting 2. Focus should be local right now as we are on cusp of right to work. Local unions need to serve their members if the want to say alive. UFT could start by getting us 2 observations. I can't believe that nobody is talking about this anymore. It is like water under the bridge. The fact is the UFT could very, very, easily get us our 2 observations. If they did this it would be a massive starting point to get the rank and file to to trust them again.

James Eterno said...

You have a greater chance of getting two observations if the Unity machine is dented at the state level.

James Eterno said...

Off topic is an understatement for the first comment.

Anonymous said...

I guess thats what happens in east flatbush when kids get the day off, im not surprised.

Anonymous said...

12:41 is just as off topic as comment one.

NYC Educator said...

This analysis is very unfair to Pallotta. In fact, shortly after his new slate took office, they were able to get NY State to change the rules. They made sure all Pallotta's NYSUT officer pals were able to collect double pensions, and would not risk being up the veritable creek without a paddle as Lee Cutler was.

Anonymous said...

I can't see how every other local would like to have the UFT running things at the state level. The majority of local state teachers unions have 2 observations and work well with their admins and school boards. The UFT on the other hand runs things like a secret cabal. The rest of NYS teachers do not want to have anything to do with them. (The UFT getting it's teachers 4 observations instead of 2 is actually a perfect example of the crap that the UFT throws at it's members)

James Eterno said...

The UFT can buy locals off. I will explain how at some point in the future.

Anonymous said...

James - it is time to remove comments like that idiot in the first comment. When the major topic of the post is totally ignored there is some rationale for doing that. Don't give him this platform. You in essence aid and abet.

James Eterno said...

I take a very wide view of the First Amendment. I know some people get very angry by the comments that are totally irrelevant to what is posted.I remind people to stay on topic frequently but I don't think those one or two people who constantly race bait here are convincing anyone of anything. I take down some of the really mean personal comments, things that are totally out there and commercial solicitations but other than that, let people express their views. We get nowhere by only talking to people that agree with us. People like the race baiters are among us in the schools. It's scary.